recently i mentioned that during recording, i prefer to do full-takes rather than punch-ins. if the tune plays from beginning to end and i’m laying down a complete track to it, i consider that a full-take.
now, lots and lots of musicians – the vast majority i guess – don’t do it this way. they do a full-take or two and the rest is kind of damage control or cosmetics or similar. so if the second half of the third chorus is not to their satisfaction, they punch in a few bars before, do the rest of the chorus, punch out again and then tinker it in there somehow. why? there’s usually two reasons: it’s supposed to save time and/or the musician is actually not able to do it all in one go and therefore needs to puzzle his track together, creating kind of a best-of-take…
back when i worked as a financial advisor (i’m serious!), i first learned about vibes – they did call it different though. in a nutshell: if you’re calling a customer to discuss business and you’re wearing a shell suit while lying on the couch, there will be no deal. i think it’s an interesting point. if you’re working, you’re working. imagine you’re going to a bank to invest some of your hard earned cash (i know, but there might be some non-musicians reading). what would you do if the banker was in a shell suit, probably hadn’t shaved in a week and was clipping his toenails behind the desk? yes, me too. of course, on the phone you wouldn’t know what he’s wearing, right?
wrong. enter the vibes. this is – among other things – about attitude. no one takes you seriously if you look like a trailerpark-inhabitant. you won’t even take yourself seriously – and that’s what the other one will know because of, tadaaaa, the vibes. on the phone, in a letter, on the moon – everywhere. is it wrong to judge someone by his outfit? maybe so, but who cares? it’s common practice.
anyway, back to recording. take it seriously. the audience will know if you did it right or if you just chose the fastest and easiest way. if you’re not capable of doing the whole tune in one continuous piece, how ’bout practicing some more? or doing it a little different? noone will miss that one guitarsolo-part where you’re playing a 20-notes-per-second-tapping-arp, believe me. what they will miss though, is a strong impact caused by your performance because it’s the work of a tinker rather than a craftsmen.
i tell my students that the song starts with the first sound there is. no matter what instrument it is, the song starts right there – for everyone. even if there’s no vocals at all for one whole minute, the song starts there. they have to dig in right there, not just a few seconds before their part starts. and they have to stay in until the last sound has vanished completely. i can get quite angry at them if this rule is not obeyed, because it is very important. the vibes are very important – and way too often underestimated. so if you record something, take it seriously.
and by the way, doing the whole track again just takes about five minutes – time well spent…